An Example of Online Atelier Feedback

I assumed it would be intriguing to share a glimpse into our On line Atelier Mentorship Plan. This is an example of a student’s latest submit to our Atelier Opinions Forum, and my reaction to her. Joy Lemon is an state-of-the-art scholar who has progressed by way of all my Classical Drawing with Graphite and Charcoal programs, my Intro to Oil Portray and Mastering Value and Shade classes, and is now doing work by the initially Indirect Portray study course. Joy has been enrolled in the software, publishing training course get the job done weekly, given that June 2020.

Hi Sadie,
One more coloration layer was included, finished in a few multi hour classes about two times.

I oiled out in the beginning and supposed to do the comprehensive layer (or a vast majority of it) and ended up doing it individually which did not work properly with the oiling out as it dried over the spots that have been completed on the second working day and application turned difficult (I should really not have done that!).

From now on I will just oil out a part of it that I hope to get to in that session. Would I still hold out a working day(s) in among for it to entirely dry just before oiling out a close by space to paint?

I was also thinking: on subsequent levels of coloration, I really don’t always will need to deal with each and every area thoroughly with paint, suitable?

Do I concentrate on what spots need perform as I move throughout the portray and leave what looks okay on your own? Can the layer even be super light [transparent] in particular parts as very long as I use medium (i.e.-the “tarnish” on the bowl’s exterior)?

For the following, and quite possibly previous go of coloration I imagine the area of the highlight on the fabric and what is about it needs to be tackled once more-that glow is so difficult to emulate-any recommendations? And possibly just one past appear at the foundation of the bowl, although I have completely missing the ellipsis and even the outer edges…augh! What else could be finished that you see? And what do you feel so significantly of my application, color, values, above all search?


Hi Pleasure!
Stunning work! I only have a few compact ideas, then I assume it is finished!

But very first, to reply your inquiries:

Oiling out:
It’s common to oil out a substantial space, or the complete portray, and then locate at the stop of the portray session that you did not paint into all all those oiled areas. When that transpires, just a bit moisten a makeup sponge with odorless mineral spirits, and wipe off the oil from the spots you did not paint into, at the conclude of the portray day, just before the oil sets. The OMS-wiped parts will be dry and completely ready to re-oil the subsequent day.

Applying paint in later layers:
Right, you will find never want to re-paint all the things with each and every layer, especially with afterwards levels. Some objects and textures will require a lot of layers, some parts will only need a few.

Transparency in later on layers:
Yes, you will discover that in later on layers you are only building extremely compact changes to suitable hue and price, so generally you only need a really skinny, clear application of the paint to nudge the hue and coloration.

As for my distinct notes for your painting:

Crimson circles:
In a couple of regions, your darkest darks have some texture that is catching smaller glimmers of light-weight as they touch the tiny peaks of black paint. These minor glimmers make the dim parts jump forward, instead of pushing again. In standard, you want any texture to be in the lights only, not not in the darks. Don’t stress about it for this painting, but in long run paintings you will want to keep away from this, by painting thinly in the darks, and also sanding down individuals ridges, bumps, and lint specks when the paint has dried.

Blue circle:
You have finished a fantastic task holding all your edges comfortable and fused through the system. But now is the time you get to sharpen! The front edge of the bowl lip (and NOT the back edge) is a wonderful position to sharpen up that edge and make it as crisp as possible. I’d also apply a little line or a handful of dots of pure white paint on the highlight of that front edge, to truly aid it pop.

Allow that back again edge to continue to be tender, which will hold it receding back into the photo plane, the place it belongs – this small bit of atmospheric viewpoint (sharp specifics at the main focal level, softer in the length) – definitely provides massive dimension to your painting, it tends to make it experience nearly like a landscape portray. It provides the drama that genuinely draws folks in, and tends to make them say “I didn’t ever feel I liked continue to daily life, but I like yours!”.

Environmentally friendly circle:
I really do not feel the ellipse is a problem – it actually seems good to me! It is a challenging shape because it’s overlapped somewhat by the material. But I feel the worth is a bit dim. Recall how the egg [the primary exercise in the Mastering Value and Color course, which Joy completed] had a misplaced edge on the underside, wherever it reflected the cloth it was sitting on so properly that they were approximately the very same benefit and hue? That’s what is going on here – the reflective airplane right wherever it touches the fabric is reflecting the cloth, so it ought to be virtually the identical price and hue as the cloth. I also believe you could lighten the pretty centre of that spotlight with a very small dabs or two of pure white paint. You can even “spackle” it on, at a microscopic stage, mainly because it is a spotlight on your major issue.

Last layer of “patina” on the front surface of the bowl:
I assume you will come across you can attain a ton with one much more translucent layer, copying what you see of the ragged, noticed, area patina of tarnish. You can even make some of these aspects have sharp, crisp edges. They will be minimal-distinction edges, so they won’t soar ahead as well significantly even if you make them sharp.

As for the glow on the material above, I consider it looks high-quality, and I really don’t consider one more layer of paint will greatly enhance it – if anything at all an additional layer will just produce more thickness and texture, which you do not want there. You also want to maintain in in a secondary position – as fairly and intriguing as it is, it needs to keep subservient to the bowl, and it is carrying out that now, whilst nevertheless on the lookout like it is experienced adequate care and notice. So I’d go away it the way it is.

For your upcoming set up, have you viewed as carrying out a direct portray? You may well want to set up just a one exciting item and attempt the “Glazing and Scumbling” course (the 1st a person, with the seashell). I think you would take pleasure in that approach. And possessing figured out what you did with this first oblique portray, and the Mastering Value and Coloration system, you will see how effective the glazing and scumbling strategy can be for achieving realism with less layers, and genuinely pushing and pulling the depth of the paint more than Oblique enables.

Permit me know your feelings,


Joy Lemon is a member of our Atelier Feedback mentorship program.
Simply click listed here to see all our mentorship applications

Leave a Reply